Ah fall… Crisp, cool air, changing leaves, and the perfect time to go shopping! I am generally a spring/summer person, but one of the things I look forward to the most when fall starts coming around is being able to give myself the excuse to spruce up my wardrobe and my makeup. Back to school shopping of sorts… It is a great time to buy a little something for myself, before all the holiday shopping begins and I have to start thinking about what I will buy for others. One of the things that I like to buy the most to give me an instant pick-me-up is a new lipstick. It can change your entire look for the day, is relatively inexpensive, and it’s fun to try on all of the different colors before picking your favorite one. I love makeup in general, but I especially like a fresh new lipstick. I do, however, want it to be a lipstick without lead or any other toxic ingredients. Below are my top picks for the best non-toxic lipstick for fall.

Best Non-Toxic Lipstick Brands and Colors for Fall


Red lipstick is a classic, especially for fall and going into winter. When wearing red, try to go with the undertones of your skin. If you have a warmer complexion, go with a shade of red that has more golden or orange undertones. If you lean towards the cool skin tones, go with a more blue based red.








Juice Beauty

Phyto-Pigments Luminous Lip Crayon in 32 Zuma (Cherry Red)








Vapour Organic Beauty

Siren Lipstick in Tryst (Universal Neutral Red Red)








Jane Iredale

Puremoist Lipstick in Cindy (Classic Red)








Burt’s Bees

Lipstick in Scarlett Soaked Red

Sandy/Mauve Pink

Pink, but toned dusty and a little more purple for fall. This is a perfect everyday shade that can work well for the office, or for date night. Look for shades that stay away from being bright or extra glossy for fall.








Juice Beauty

Phyto-Pigments Luminous Lip Crayon in 24 Laguna (Pink Mauve)









Mineral Fusion

Sheer Moisture Lip Tint in Blush







Honest Beauty

Truly Kissable Lip Crayon in Marsala Kiss (Muted Mauve)

Deep Plum

There is not a lipstick shade out there that says fall more than a deep plum color. It is a dramatic look that is usually a very sophisticated show stopper. Finding this shade in a non-toxic or organic lipstick is a big bonus.








Shea Moisture

Shea Butter Ultra Shine Lip Gloss in Loredana







Vapour Organic Beauty

Siren Lipstick in Torrid









Mineral Fusion

Lipstick Butter in Blackberry

Rose/Rose Brown

Rose is an all-around universal color for most people. Lean towards the brownish rose hues and you are right on trend for fall.








Juice Beauty

Phyto-Pigments Luminous Lip Crayon in 28 Salinas (Rosy Brown)








Honest Beauty

Truly Kissable Lip Crayon Sheer in Rose Kiss









Devocean Natural Lipstick in Tenderness

Deep Berry/Plum

Plum colored lipstick is synonymous with fall. Look for a medium purple with a hint of red or that reads more neutral.








Burt’s Bees

Lipstick in Juniper Water







Jane Iredale

Puremoist Lipstick in Mary






Mineral Fusion

Lipstick in Gem

If you are looking for a more natural lipstick or even an organic lipstick for fall, one of these will definitely fill the bill. I own a lot of these already and they are in constant rotation.

What non-toxic lipstick brands and colors do you turn to in the fall? Let me know in the comments!

Disclaimer: Please note that some of the links in this post are affiliate links and I will earn a commission if you purchase through those links. I recommend these products because they are products that I personally use or companies that I have found trustworthy.